Log In

10 Best Stephen King Movies With the Worst Endings

Published 4 weeks ago8 minute read

When it comes to modern horror, few creators compare to Stephen King. As one of the most frequently-adapted authors in history, his popular stories have been transformed into some of the most successful genre films out there. However, they can't all be masterpieces, and many of them don't live up to their strong starts. This list contains ten of the best Stephen King films that just couldn't stick the landing.

Each of these famous adaptations, sequels, prequels, and remakes has something to offer, but their conclusions hold them back from greatness. Sometimes it's the filmmaker's mistake, some endings have just aged poorly, and sometimes fans must accept that even Stephen King is fallible. This list of flawed but fascinating films helps illuminate what makes a great story, and how easy it is to fall short of perfection — even for the master.

Pennywise (Tim Curry) is in the sewer talking to Georgie in Stephen King's It (1990).
Image via ABC

Stephen King's It would be challenging for anyone to adapt. For this tale of childhood friends reuniting to fight an entity that manifests their deepest fears, one needs fourteen great performances for the old and young versions of seven heroes — and the FX must be excellent.

It's creative team was leery of Stephen King's monster movie conclusion, in which the gang fights a giant spider, and no one was satisfied with how they brought it to life. Actor Tim Reid addressed the struggle humorously in a Yahoo TV interview celebrating the adaptation's 25th anniversary.

The emotional aspects of the story were what I liked most...the things we encounter in life that shape us. I didn’t think the spider was up to par with the rest of the story. I was like, 'Get some Raid and spray it, and let’s move on.'

The zombified Gus Gilbert (Clancy Brown) driving a car in Pet Sematary 2.
Image via Paramount Pictures.

Even Mary Lambert chased her excellent 1989 adaption with Pet Sematary 2, about teens (Edward Furlong and Jason McGuire) who foolishly use the burial ground's resurrection powers to fix their tragedy-stricken families. The film is occasionally moving, and Clancy Brown steals the show as a zombified stepdad, but ultimately the story falls apart.

Stephen King had his name removed from Pet Sematary 2 before its release.

The zombies of his best friend's abusive stepfather and the town bully crash the party, diluting the message about a youth learning to accept mortality. Lambert claimed that the original hero of Pet Sematary 2 was Ellie Creed, the first film's sole survivor, but Paramount didn't believe a teenage girl could carry the movie. That choice could have produced a more focused story.

Pet Sematary II
Pet Sematary II

August 28, 1992

100 minutes

Timothy Hutton as George Stark and Thad Beaumont in The Dark Half.
Image via Scream Factory.

When author Thad Beaumont retires the pen name he uses on grisly pulp novels, his literary alter ego George Stark manifests in the flesh, demanding that Thad continue their collaboration. George A. Romero's The Dark Half: ancient mythology and medical anomalies combine confusingly to explain Stark's existence, adding up to a muddled conclusion.

King-Romero Feature Film Collaborations

In a Washington Post interview, the author made a telling remark about the Bachman books that may explain his less satisfying endings.

They all have downbeat endings. I don't think the ending of a novel is particularly important...I'm more interested in how people react along the way. As far as we're concerned, we're all going to come to an unhappy ending.

Dussander (Ian McKellen) threatens Todd (Brad Renfro) with a cracked bottle in Apt Pupil.
Image via Sony Pictures Releasing.

Stellar performances from major horror stars uplift the most unpleasant of all Stephen King adaptations: Apt Pupil, in which a sociopathic high school student matches wits with a Nazi war criminal. Todd (Brad Renfro) blackmails the aged Dussander (Ian McKellen) into discussing his horrific past, and their mutual excitement inspires fresh crimes.

In the original Stephen King story, Todd commits a mass shooting, illustrating the way violence ultimately consumes its perpetrators. Bryan Singer's cynical adaptation is true to life in its own way, but this reading is profoundly disturbing in light of the many criminal allegations against the filmmaker.

pu3fvfsvrs5pzfdodpczolk95ws.jpg
Apt Pupil

October 23, 1998

111 Minutes

Mort and John have an intense moment in Secret Window.
Image via Columbia Pictures

— As Shooter becomes increasingly dangerous, Rainey realizes that this is all in his own mind. Finally, the Shooter personality takes over and restores his desired "ending": the murder of Rainey's estranged wife.

On his website, Stephen King states that he refuses to read and critique other people's manuscripts specifically to avoid future plagiarism accusations.

Secret Window starts strong with the mystery of whether Rainey could have plagiarized Shooter without realizing it. In the original King story "Secret Window, Secret Garden," Shooter is a supernatural presence who impugns Rainey's sanity.

secret-window-poster-johnny-depp.jpg
Secret Window

March 12, 2004

David Koepp

Split Images of Joker, Shutter Island, PSycho, midsommar, and Me Myself and Irene

Related

25 Movies That Inaccurately Portray Mental Health Conditions

Mental health is often at the center of a character's journey, but movies like Split and The Shining inaccurately portray mental health conditions.

Mike (John Cusack) stares at a hangman's noose in room 1408.
Image via MGM.

There he experiences deadly delusions, some involving his daughter's tragic death. After destroying the room, he plays his wife a recording of a ghostly voice imitating their child, proving the haunting was real. But is that really the moral of the story?

Stephen King originally wrote the first few pages of 1408 to demonstrate his editing techniques in his book On Writing.

The former two endings exist because the latter tested so poorly, but when endings can be changed arbitrarily, it suggests that the story itself doesn't have a major point to make.

1408-movie-poster.jpg
1408

June 22, 2007

112 Minutes

David (Thomas Jane) collapses as military men approach in The Mist.
Image via MGM.

In The Mist, a small-town supermarket is the last stronghold against a Lovecraftian horror that descends on the United States. The film plays like a pulse-pounding supernatural thriller with some cheeky political commentary, up until a jarring tonal shift rips the rug out from under the audience.

Stephen King Adaptations by Frank Darabont

  • The Green Mile (1999)
  • The Mist (2007)

King's 1980 novella The Mist ends with a small group escaping the supermarket in hopes of finding other survivors. Downbeat endings have their place, but with Darabont's breezy action movie style, the mercilessly tragic conclusion feels unearned.

the-mist-movie-poster.jpg
The Mist

November 21, 2007

126 minutes

Manny (Forrest Goodluck) and Donna (Isabella Star LaBlanc) stand among sunflowers in Pet Sematary: Bloodlines.
Image via Paramount Pictures.

The underrated Pet Sematary: Bloodlines has a lot to offer — up until its uninspired climax. In 1969, the town of Ludlow is fraught with drama; while families lose their sons to the Vietnam War, the Indigenous American community suffers as they have since the settler days.

While the original Pet Sematary is truly great, it is sadly synonymous with the problematic "Indian burial ground" trope. Pet Sematary: Bloodlines actually includes Indigenous main characters (played by Forrest Goodluck and Isabella Star LaBlanc), and addresses the effects of American imperialism at home and abroad.

Pet Sematary Bloodlines Movie Poster
Pet Sematary: Bloodlines

October 6, 2023

Lindsey Beer

Danny guards the staircase with an axe in Doctor Sleep
Image via Warner Bros.
 

Stanley Kubrick's The Shining was famously disdained by Stephen King for its shallowness. When Mike Flanagan chose to adapt the sequel novel Doctor Sleep, about the grownup Danny Torrence grappling with his powers, King declared the haunted Overlook Hotel must not appear in the film. However, Flanagan felt that directly addressing The Shining was unavoidable, as he told Entertainment Weekly.

(The Shining) has burned itself into the collective imagination... If you say 'Overlook Hotel,' I see something. It lives right up in my brain because of Stanley Kubrick. You can't pretend that isn't the case.

Flanagan was right to revisit the Overlook to meet viewer expectations (the novel's climax occurs where the hotel once stood), but Danny's new adventure doesn't convincingly connect with The Shining. It is also troublesome that Danny's psychic teen sidekick (Kyliegh Curran) is so powerful that it ultimately lowers the stakes.

doctor-sleep-official-poster.jpg
Doctor Sleep

October 30, 2019

Runtime
153 minutes

Ewan McGregor as Dan Torrance looks at a mirror refelecting REDRUM and actually saying murder in Doctor Sleep

Related

The Biggest Differences Between the Dr. Sleep Movie and Book, Explained

The Doctor Sleep film does a great job of adapting Stephen King's novel, but there are still several notable differences between the two projects.

The Boogeyman's ghoul hides under Sawyer's bed
Image via 20th Century Studios.

In The Boogeyman's best scene, a haunted man (David Dastmalchian) claims his family was destroyed by "the thing that comes for your kids when you're not paying attention." This supernatural being preys on the mental anguish of bereaved families, a sophisticated modus operandi that should call for an equally sophisticated defense...which makes its actual weakness a bit of a letdown.

When the Boogeyman roosts in the home of grieving teen Sadie (Sophie Thatcher), she goes on an often-thrilling odyssey to learn how to defeat it before it devours her family. At the end of all her travails, it turns out that the creature is easily dispatched with a blowtorch. Disappointing as this may be, the real problem with The Boogeyman is that it simply does not have enough David Dastmalchian.

inception, lost in translation, mullholand drive

Related

10 Most Ambiguous Movie Endings of All Time, Ranked

From Inception to American Psycho, some of the best film endings leave things open to further interpretation.

Origin:
publisher logo
CBR
Loading...
Loading...

You may also like...