The revitalization of Greenport, a village on Long Island, is largely credited to Latino migrants from Mexico and Central America who have settled there over the past 30 years.

Today, Latinos make up about 35% of the population, and many work in local farms, vineyards, and businesses. However, the village recently became a target of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) operations.

Last Wednesday morning, ICE agents arrested three longtime residents—Hugo Leonel Ardon Osorio, Martir Zambrano Diaz, and Alexandro Rivera Magaña.

According to Local Advocacy Group OLA of Eastern Long Island, the men had no criminal records, had lived in the community for more than 20 years, and had families and steady jobs.

Their arrests caused fear in the community, leading to a 25% drop in school attendance as families worried about further detentions.

These arrests have raised questions about the Trump administration’s deportation policies, which were described as targeting the “worst of the worst.”

However, many of those arrested, including the Greenport men, reportedly had no criminal history.

Local officials said the arrests are creating fear, damaging trust between immigrants and police, and harming community safety.

Former Greenport Mayor Dave Kapell warned that deporting immigrants could seriously hurt the local economy.

He said immigrants are essential workers in agriculture, vineyards, and local businesses, and losing them would be an “absolute disaster.”

In Nassau County, officials have supported stronger cooperation with ICE.

County Executive Bruce Blakeman has allowed local police to work with immigration authorities under federal law.

This has led to protests, with demonstrators calling for “ICE out of Long Island.” Activists say immigration enforcement is causing fear and separating families.

Meanwhile, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has taken the opposite approach. He has strengthened the city’s sanctuary policies, limiting cooperation with ICE and protecting immigrants unless there is a serious criminal case.

He said the city’s approach focuses on “compassion” and protecting residents’ rights.

Experts say these different policies show a growing divide.

Some areas are increasing immigration enforcement, while others are trying to protect immigrant communities.

For many residents of Greenport and Long Island, the issue has become a major concern affecting families, the economy, and community stability.