Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay, remembered for his significant contributions to addiction recovery efforts, has left a lasting impact on the city of Indianapolis. Organizations and individuals who benefited from his support have expressed their gratitude, emphasizing his off-field actions as his most meaningful legacy.

Pathway to Recovery, an organization providing transitional and permanent housing for unhoused individuals affected by substance use and mental health disorders, displayed a sign stating, "Rest in peace, Jim Irsay. Thank you for always being our #1 fan." Executive Director Sandy Jeffers highlighted Irsay's genuine care for those often overlooked. Irsay, a former addict himself, connected with individuals at Pathway to Recovery on a personal level, offering support without seeking recognition.

Jeffers recounted an instance where Irsay funded rehab for Pathway’s board president, who was also a Colts employee. Furthermore, Irsay recently donated half a million dollars to establish the Colts Connection Center, which will provide 21 affordable, substance-free housing units. This center is scheduled to open later this year in his honor.

Wheeler Mission, another Indianapolis community pillar, has also been significantly impacted by Irsay’s generosity. Brian Crispin, Chief Marketing and Communications Officer at Wheeler Mission, stated that Irsay has donated close to half a million dollars during his tenure. These contributions include funding for the expansion of the men’s center and a $100,000 donation towards the Center for Women and Children.