Before Brad and Angelina, and Kylie and Timothée, there was John F Kennedy Jr and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy – the ultimate It-couple of the ’90s. Effortlessly chic yet impossibly elusive, the pair were the American dream personified. But while JFK Jr may have had the famous surname, it was Carolyn’s minimalist style that cemented her status as a fashion icon. With her platinum locks, barely-there make-up and a wardrobe that whispered quiet luxury long before the term took over TikTok, she defined an era of sleek, sophisticated simplicity that’s still beloved by A-listers and the street-style set alike.

Now, nearly 30 years after she became the ultimate New York muse, Hollywood is preparing to revisit her story. Taking on the challenge? Ryan Murphy of American Horror Story fame. The director has turned his lens on some of America’s most compelling figures, from Gianni Versace and Monica Lewinsky to the equally memorable – but fictional – Sue Sylvester. His latest project, American Love Story, will chronicle the whirlwind romance and tragic fate of JFK Jr and CBK, bringing their love story and impeccable style back into the spotlight.

When it came to casting the leading lady, speculation was inevitable. Who could possibly embody a woman who’s been immortalised in the fashion history books? Enter Tiny Beautiful Things and Stereophonic star Sarah Pidgeon. Best known for her emotionally charged performances, Sarah also happens to have a natural affinity for the kind of unfussy, polished dressing that made CBK a street-style icon. And while she’s a brunette, for now, a little bleach can work wonders.

As we count down the days to the official release date (and news on who will be taking on the role of JFK Jr), one thing is certain: Pidgeon’s method dressing is well underway. From pared-back evening wear to her effortlessly chic off-duty ensembles, she’s already stepping into her CBK era. Scroll down for eight looks that prove she was made for the role.