Mafia: The Old Country is managing expectations by announcing a $49.99 price point and confirming it's a linear, narrative-driven game, not open-world. Developed by Hangar 13, the gangster shooter showcased new gameplay, distinguishing itself from GTA 6 and even Mafia III. 2K President David Ismailer emphasized the game's appeal to those who prefer compelling stories without massive time commitments, suggesting a shorter experience without a multiplayer mode.

Comparisons to GTA 6 were dismissed in a previous interview with Hangar 13 President Nick Baynes and game director Alex Cox, who highlighted Mafia: The Old Country's resemblance to Mafia 1 and 2, focusing on a “linear, narrative-driven” and “cinematic experience.” While players might explore 1900s Sicily, similarities to Rockstar games end there.

Despite some complaints about the scope, there is positivity regarding the game's offering. Many appreciate a high-quality, shorter, story-driven Mafia game over a bloated open-world experience. The success of Sandfall’s Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, with 2 million copies sold despite being on Game Pass, is seen as a potential trendsetter for these types of games, especially as game prices rise.

Reactions across social media reflect this sentiment. Some users said they are more inclined to purchase Mafia: The Old Country due to its $50 price and focused gameplay. Others expressed a preference for a shorter, linear experience over an empty open world.

Ultimately, sales of Mafia: The Old Country will determine its success and the franchise's future. The game's performance will be a key indicator of whether the success of games like Clair Obscur can translate into a sustainable trend within the video game industry.