declined to appear on McAfee’s program. Instead, Schefter opted to participate in a free agency special on ESPN2, which apparently caused friction between the two ESPN colleagues.

The situation has created notable tension within the network, with McAfee allegedly removing Schefter from his regular appearance slot. While Schefter has been absent from the show since March, fellow NFL reporter Ian Rapoport has become a regular guest. Despite the reported ban, sources indicate Schefter may return to the program soon, suggesting a potential thawing in their professional relationship. ESPN executives, including Burke Magnus, have reportedly downplayed the situation, describing it as merely a “rumor” while defending McAfee’s position at the network.

Since joining ESPN in 2023 as part of an $85 million deal, Pat McAfee has created a significant impact on the network. ESPN president of content Burke Magnus has expressed satisfaction with the partnership, noting that McAfee and his show are “thriving” despite external skepticism.

“The Pat McAfee Show” has successfully attracted millions of viewers to ESPN’s platforms. Digital performance has been particularly strong, with show clips accumulating impressive viewership across YouTube, the ESPN app, and various social media channels.

However, McAfee’s tenure hasn’t been without turbulence. Several controversies have marked his time at the network:

As of June 2025, new tensions have emerged between McAfee and longtime ESPN insider Adam Schefter. Recent reports indicate Schefter has been “banned” from appearing on McAfee’s show, suggesting growing friction between the ESPN colleagues.

Despite these challenges, the partnership continues to evolve. Magnus has defended McAfee against critics, stating: “We’ve continuously seen those out there that are seemingly obsessed with wanting to see Pat fail on ESPN.” The network appears committed to the relationship, with Magnus adding they “look forward to the continued success together.”

McAfee’s unique approach continues to “break the mold and reach new audiences” according to ESPN leadership, even as his controversial moments generate headlines alongside his programming successes.