The smell of drug store bug spray might make some people nostalgic for childhood summers, but it just makes my nose wrinkle.

If you’re sensitive to harsh chemical smells, you’re probably already with me on this. While Deet, the repelling agent in most bug sprays, has been cleared by the FDA, it can still be toxic if the concentration is over 30%, and skin reactions are possible, especially with overexposure.

The synthetic compound Picardin is often suggested as an alternative, but it can also cause irritation. That’s why we recommend opting for insect repellents made from natural ingredients, like the ones listed below. We’ve tried them out, , and curated this collection of the most effective natural options.

We’re long-term fans of Meow Meow Tweet, and its bug spray doesn’t disappoint. The vegan brand only uses regenerative ingredients, and it specializes in refillable packaging. It’s Anabelle’s summer essential for its effectiveness and pleasant smell.

This low-waste brand makes small-batch self-care products in recyclable packaging. Alden loved it, as did the friends she shared it with! It smells great and seems to keep mosquitoes away without a problem.

If you’re looking for a repellent that’s a bit different from a spray, the Kate McLeod dusk stone might be for you. It’s made with cocoa butter concentrate, natural fragrances, and natural repellents. Alden found it luxurious to use, but a bit difficult to pass around to share with friends.

Kinfield makes a variety of bug repellent (and itch relief!) products, including repellent wipes, sprays, anti-itch balm, and patches for bug bites. Its products are made with Indonesian citronella, and are free of phthalates and parabens. Alden found it to be too strong for her taste, but effective.