Log In

All 5 Osgood Perkins Movies, Ranked

Published 1 month ago6 minute read
The Monkey - poster - 2025
Image via NEON

had his start in the world of film as an actor, first appearing as a child in , playing the younger version of Norman Bates (the role his father, , was most well-known for playing). The younger Perkins had a few more acting credits over the next handful of decades, but is now more well-recognized for his directorial work. Since 2015, he’s made a series of movies that could all be categorized as horror, but most belong to other genres, too. And that’s part of what makes his filmography, to date, quite interesting. He takes risks and goes to some weird places tonally speaking, too.

Perkins’ distinct style means his work isn’t going to be for everyone. His work has a somewhat consistent vibe, highlighting uncanniness that’s sometimes eerie, and sometimes muddy/off-putting in a distracting way. That’s . Even his lesser films still have aspects worth celebrating, and celebrating is what the following ranking intends to do. Every feature film Osgood Perkins has directed to date is ranked below, starting with a slight misfire of a movie and ending with his best work as a filmmaker so far.

A close up of Polly (Lucy Boynton) wearing a white Victorian-era gown and a black hat, staring offscreen slightly ahead and to the left with a frightened expression in I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House
Image via Netflix

The Osgood Perkins movie with the longest title, , is also perhaps his simplest and most direct work of horror to date. Part of that simplicity comes about because of how stripped back this is, taking place in a confined setting and having very few characters who play a significant role in the story. Oh, and further contributing to that simplicity is the fact that said story is very slight here, following a nurse as she takes care of an elderly writer who’s not far from death’s door, all within her strange home.

That makes it all an example of a slow-burn horror movie, but the stuff here probably burns a little too slowly, if it even burns at all.

That home seems to be haunted by something, but I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House doesn’t want to let you know what that is until the last moment possible. So, that makes it all . It was admirable to attempt to make something this small-scale and deliberately paced, but I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House does end up feeling like a short film stretched to a feature-length runtime in a manner that cannot be described as seamless or even justified. It's atmospheric and occasionally psychologically unsettling, but that's about it.

Kiernan Shipka as Kat standing in the snow in The Blackcoat's Daughter
Image via A24

was Osgood Perkins’ feature directorial debut, and he certainly succeeded here in establishing his voice as a filmmaker, all the while introducing certain ideas and themes he’d explore in later films, arguably more successfully. Like with I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House, the plot in The Blackcoat’s Daughter feels secondary to things like atmosphere and a general sense of unease, but there is slightly more going on narratively, if you can make sense of it all. There’s some kind of presence possessing young women at a prep school, and a handful of characters are all impacted by it in different ways, with the film jumping between them sometimes jarringly.

Things come together by the (rather downbeat) end, which does make The Blackcoat’s Daughter ultimately make some sort of twisted sense. . You do feel the coldness of the film’s setting, and it’s a great horror movie to watch during the winter months; pair it with the equally snowy , if, for whatever reason, you want to watch a chilly horror movie and Western back to back and feel absolutely miserable at the end of it all.

Gretel (Sophia Lillis) stands in a witch's alluring home, basked in warm golden light in 'Gretel & Hansel' (2020)
Image via United Artists Releasing

As you might have guessed from the title, puts a spin on the fairy tale by the . It’s perhaps more of a fantasy movie than it is a horror film, but that’s not a problem when it’s so distinct and visually bold. In terms of pure atmosphere, set design, and overall aesthetics, it might well be Osgood Perkins’ strongest film. On a narrative front, it’s not quite as compelling, but it’s well worth checking out simply for the way it looks and sounds, with cinematographer contributing greatly to the former, and composer (AKA ) being responsible for the latter.

You definitely get a folk horror vibe here, too, and Gretel & Hansel is far from the only recent movie to help revitalize that particular strand of horror. It’s not a movie that sustains itself entirely for all 87 minutes of its runtime, which is something of an issue, considering 87 minutes isn’t all that long, but when it works, it really works. You can compare it to things like and if you want, but Gretel & Hansel does also do its own thing, .

A toy monkey with a creepy grin holding a drumstick in the air while looking at the camera in The Monkey.
Image via Neon

It wouldn’t be entirely accurate to say adaptations have been on the rise popularity-wise lately, since the author’s works have been popular ones to adapt right from the very start (see , for example). But is one of a handful released in 2025, and a pretty damn good one at that. Osgood Perkins takes the short story of the same name and expands it where necessary, while also playing up the comedy to a greater extent. In fact, The Monkey is best approached as a dark comedy more than a horror movie, with it being about a wind-up “toy” monkey that, when activated, causes a mysterious and grisly death to happen somewhere in its vicinity.

Twin brothers come across it when they're kids, then they bury it, but a quarter of a century later, weird deaths start happening again, creating the distinct possibility that the titular monkey is back. . If you want to be truly scared, you might well be let down by the tone The Monkey ultimately goes for, but if you're after a horror-comedy hybrid, this is one of the best of the 2020s so far.

01709096_poster_w780.jpg
The Monkey

February 19, 2025

98 Minutes

might well have been the movie that put Osgood Perkins on the map as a horror director, finding a wider audience than his previous three movies had. And it deserved that larger audience, because it was bolder and arguably better than the Perkins-directed films that came before it. At its core, Longlegs is . What begins as an unnerving crime/thriller film eventually becomes… well, something else. Kind of. But to say more would be doing the film a disservice.

It's worth sticking with, and you kind of have to just go with the wild turns the film takes as they come. When you’ve got a bizarre performance, that certainly helps, though, and in the central role here is also very good. The atmosphere Longlegs conjures up is also hard to resist, if you have a thing for uncanny and persistently eerie horror, and the genres it chooses to blend are generally in some sort of strange harmony here. Longlegs might not quite be flawless, but it is striking and succeeds in lingering in one’s mind once it’s over, in turn being representative of Osgood Perkins at his best (so far) as a filmmaker.

Longlegs 2024 Movie Poster
Longlegs

Release Date
July 12, 2024

Runtime
101 Minutes

NEXT: Great Movies You'll Need a Strong Stomach to Get Through

Origin:
publisher logo
Collider
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

You may also like...