Log In

10 Best Movies With Silent Protagonists, Ranked

Published 1 month ago9 minute read

Having a silent protagonist is a tough challenge. It means that filmmakers must rely on visual cues, gestures, and expressions to convey meaning and characterization. This is a tricky feat to pull off, but a few movies nevertheless do it well. Their protagonists don't speak, yet the audience still gets a clear sense of their personality. Whether through stoic resilience or quiet contemplation, these silent heroes leave a lasting impression.

With this in mind, this list looks at some of the very best movies with main characters who never (or almost never speak). Each of the following films approaches its silent protagonist in a different way, turning their lack of speech into an asset. From arthouse cinema to historical dramas,.

valhalla rising0

"We are more than flesh and blood. More than revenge." Danish legends and teamed up for this . The former is One Eye, a mute Norse warrior with a fearsome reputation. Imprisoned and used as a fighting slave, he escapes his captors with the help of a young boy and joins a group of Christian crusaders on their journey to the Holy Land.

From this simple premise, . It's violent as hell but also visually beautiful, boasting Refn's trademark meticulously composed shots. In particular, his minimalist approach emphasizes the stark landscapes. It's a treat just to look at the forests, crags, and threatening gray skies. Story-wise, the director draws inspiration from the likes of and , making Valhalla Rising a lot more interesting than the average revenge-o-matic.

valhalla-rising-2009-poster-mads-mikkelsen.jpg

Valhalla Rising

March 31, 2010

Nicolas Winding Refn

Mads Mikkelsen , Gary Lewis , Jamie Sives , Ewan Stewart , Alexander Morton

1h 33m

Brion James and Sharee J. Wilson in 'Crimewave'
Image via Columbia Pictures

"I’d always wanted to make the greatest crime movie ever made." is a surreal Canadian indie film about aspiring screenwriter Steven Penny (, who also directed, produced, wrote the script, and handled the cinematography) who struggles to create the perfect crime screenplay, but his inability to write dialogue leaves his characters trapped in silence. , as much a satire of genre tropes as it is a meditation on artistic frustration.

The screenwriter himself never speaks; instead, most of the info is conveyed to the audience by the neighbor's daughter (), who narrates. Crime Wave is incredibly wacky, continuously breaking the fourth wall and containing stories with stories. It keeps ratcheting up the madness as it rolls along, culminating in a wild finale. Along the way, Paizs pays homage to countless B-movies and noir gems, while adding a gonzo sensibility that's all his own. For all these reasons, Crime Wave has become .

Crime Wave

April 12, 1985

John Paizs

Eva Kovacs , John Paizs , Darrell Baran , Mark Yuill , Neil Lawrie , Martin Bresin , Angela Heck , M.B. Duggan

80 minutes

"Where are you going, Mr. Hulot?" is one of the , a master of physical comedy. I, who had charmed audiences with and . Here, Hulot is trying to deliver a prototype camping car to an auto show in Amsterdam. Ever the silent yet expressive protagonist, he quickly becomes entangled in a series of comedic mishaps, from customs issues to breakdowns.

The movie is a whirlwind of choreographed sight gags and understated humor. While not every joke lands, some of them manage to be both hilarious and insightful, gently mocking consumerism and people's reliance on technology. Hulot stumbles his way through this mechanized, dehumanized landscape, clearly yearning for the simpler good old days. While not as polished and focused as Playtime, Trafic is still an enjoyable collection of moments, with Tati saying so much by saying so little.

Watch on Criterion

The-Piano-1993
Image Via Miramax

"The voice you hear is not my speaking voice - but my mind's voice." Among , this devastating historical drama tells the story of Ada McGrath (), a mute pianist, who is sent to New Zealand with her daughter Flora () for an arranged marriage with a settler, Alisdair Stewart (). There, she finds herself entangled in a passionate, complicated relationship with Alisdair's neighbor, Baines ().

Although Ada talks to the viewer via voice-over, her primary means of communication with the other characters is her piano and, after that, her daughter. . Hunter rises to the occasion with a performance full of feeling, rightly winning her the Oscar (Paquin, then just 11, won for Best Supporting Actress). The performances are complemented by the haunting imagery; the romantic scenes between Ada and Baines are particularly rich in symbolism.

the-piano-poster.jpg

The Piano

November 12, 1993

Jane Campion

Holly Hunter , Harvey Keitel , Sam Neill , Anna Paquin , Cliff Curtis , Kerry Walker , Ian Mune , Pete Smith , Bruce Allpress , Verity George , Stephen Papps , Karen Colston , Eddie Campbell , Te Whatanui Skipwith , Tungia Baker , Neil Gudsell , Jon Sperry , Greg Mayor

117 Minutes

a man and a woman are sitting on the bed

"Revenge is never a straight line. It’s a forest." In this neo-noir thriller, a deaf-mute factory worker named Ryu () turns to organ trafficking in a desperate bid to save his sister's life. When his plan goes horribly wrong, it sets off a chain of events that leads to a cycle of revenge between Ryu and the grieving father of a kidnapped child, Dong-jin (). , which forces the audience to focus on his actions and physicality.

While not on the level of , is still a stylish and intense affair, once again demonstrating 's visual prowess. It's gritty too; plot-wise, moral ambiguity and human suffering are the order of the day. The characters don't leap off the scream in the same way, and the themes are a little harder to parse, but it's an undeniably hard-hitting crime film nevertheless.

sympathy-for-mr-vengeance_movie_poster.jpg

Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance

March 29, 2002

Chan-wook Park

Kang-ho Song , Ha-kyun Shin , Doona Bae , Ji-Eun Lim , Bo-bae Han , Se-dong Kim

121 minutes

Anne Wiazemsky in 'Au Hasard Balthazar' (1966)

"Life's nothing but a fairground, a marketplace where even your word is unnecessary." is a simple yet , the director behind and . It revolves around a donkey who passes through the hands of various owners, each representing different facets of human nature. inherent in humanity.

A lighthearted movie, this is not. Au Hasard Balthazar is meditative rather than escapist, meaning that the viewer has to be in the right frame of mind to enjoy it. This is a deep story, laden with allegory, that is bound to linger on the mind long after the credits have rolled. Among Bresson's most acclaimed projects, the movie has been embraced by everyone from and to , , and .

Au Hasard Balthazar movie poster

Au Hasard Balthazar

May 25, 1966

Robert Bresson

Anne Wiazemsky , Walter Green , François Lafarge , Philippe Asselin , Nathalie Joyaut

95 Minutes

Klaus Kinski pointing a gun in The Great Silence
Image via 20th Century Fox

"He avenges our wrongs. And the bounty killers sure do tremble when he appears." is a bleak, subversive Western from , perhaps most famous for directing the original . The main character is the fittingly titled Silence (), a mute gunslinger who protects settlers from the sadistic Loco () and his bounty hunters.

. In particular, Corbucci takes shots at corrupt capitalists and untrustworthy authorities. The movie is skeptical of heroism, with even the heroes either failing or marred by serious vices of their own. Consequently, The Great Silence is one of the director's strongest and most audacious works. The plot is bleak, the characters morally gray, the landscapes oppressive, and the music by the great hits all the right notes. Western fans should give it a try; many will also enjoy spotting its influence on .

The Great Silence Film Poster

The Great Silence

January 27, 1969

Sergio Corbucci

Jean-Louis Trintignant , Klaus Kinski , Frank Wolff , Luigi Pistilli , Mario Brega , Carlo D'Angelo , Marisa Merlini , Maria Mizar

105 Minutes

Watch on Hoopla

"It's hard to tell that the world we live in is either a reality or a dream." This explores connection and isolation through the silent actions of its protagonist, Tae-suk (). A drifter who breaks into empty homes, Tae-suk lives a quiet and invisible existence until he encounters Sun-hwa (), an abused woman who joins him in his escapades. United by their similar situations, the two develop an intimate bond - without exchanging a single word.

While it may not be for everyone, , conjuring up a dreamy atmosphere, suffused with romance and yearning. The storytelling is light-touch, almost ghostly, and open to endless interpretation. The silent protagonist is a key part of this. As director explains: "I want the audience to watch the characters more closely by reducing the dialogue as much as possible. Most movies have too much dialogue; I don't think words make everything understandable."

Rent on Apple TV

A naked man walking in a color painted with the rainbow's color in 'The Holy Mountain'
Image via ABKCO Films

"Prisoners! We shall break the illusion. is a famously trippy filmmaker, and might be his most surreal movie of all. Less a traditional narrative and more an avant-garde odyssey, it follows a Christ-like figure (), referred to as The Thief, on a journey of spiritual awakening and self-discovery. Guided by an alchemist (played by Jodorowsky himself), The Thief and a group of seekers embark on a quest to ascend the mountain and replace the gods who reside at its peak.

. Here, Jodorowsky's vision is gloriously deranged, a mishmash of countercultural ideas gone awry. In this regard, The Holy Mountain very much feels like an artifact from the psychedelic era. It's either incredibly wise or utterly devoid of meaning, depending on the viewer, but it deserves kudos for its sheer ingenuity and ambition.

the-holy-mountain-poster.jpg

The Holy Mountain

November 29, 1973

Alejandro Jodorowsky

Cast
Alejandro Jodorowsky , Horacio Salinas , Zamira Saunders , Juan Ferrara , Adriana Page , Burt Kleiner , Valerie Jodorowsky , Nicky Nichols , Richard Rutowski , Luis Lomelí , Ana De Sade , Jacqueline Voltaire , Chucho-Chucho , Letícia Robles , Connie De La Mora , David Kapralik , Pablo Leder , Bobby Cameron , Re Debris , Lupita Peruyero , José Antonio Alcaraz , Héctor Ortega , Robert Taicher , Arielle Dombasle , Manuel Dondé

Runtime
114 minutes

the-artist-jean-dujardin-Bérénice-Bejo
Image via Warner Bros. France

"I won't talk! I won't say a word!" Claiming the top spot on this list is The Artist, one of the most affectionate cinematic love letters to the silent era. Jean Dujardin leads the cast as George Valentin, a silent movie story struggling to adapt as Hollywood transitions to talkies. The story is enriched by the parallel ascent of Peppy Miller (Bérénice Bejo), a rising star whose charm and optimism contrast George’s downward spiral.

The Artist plays well with the conventions of silent film, using title cards for humor, drama, and misdirection. The movie was embraced on release, going on to win Best Picture, but has since seemed to have slipped a little in the popular consciousness. Maybe its Oscar success has led someone to consider it overrated. Still, The Artist remains one of the most entertaining and clever movies about a protagonist who doesn't speak, one that uses silence and sound for maximum effect.

NEXT: The Most Overlooked James Bond Movies, Ranked

Origin:
publisher logo
Collider
Loading...
Loading...

You may also like...