The 22-year-old Grammy winner appeared affectionate with Wolff, known for roles in Paper Towns and The Naked Brothers Band, during what looked like a romantic Italian getaway.

Fans were quick to bring up Eilish's 2023 Variety interview, in which she admitted to being 'attracted to women.'

Though she didn't explicitly label her sexuality, her openness about same-sex attraction had led many to view her as part of the LGBTQ+ community.

The newly surfaced photos with Wolff have reignited conversations about whether her earlier statements were misleading.

This isn't the first time Billie Eilish's comments or visuals have sparked debate about her sexuality.

In 2021, the music video for Lost Cause—featuring an all-female cast in intimate scenes—was accused of queerbaiting. She captioned behind-the-scenes photos from the shoot with 'I love girls,' which some fans interpreted as a coming-out moment. Eilish never clarified the post.

Jojo siwa, fletcher, clairo and billie eilish got a man during this pride month and it's only 8th day of it. Should we wait for plot twist from Ellen DeGeneres? pic.twitter.com/oBQLyaRK0a

— jesus (@whitegirl2137) June 8, 2025

On platforms like X (formerly Twitter) and TikTok, many users criticised her for what they see as inconsistent messaging. Some expressed disappointment, believing she had positioned herself within the queer community.

Others defended her, highlighting that sexuality can be fluid and that being seen with a man doesn't invalidate attraction to women.

Neither Billie Eilish nor Nat Wolff has commented publicly on the viral images. Eilish has long preferred to keep her dating life private and rarely addresses tabloid coverage or fan speculation.

As discussions around the Billie Eilish kiss in Venice continue to trend, the situation underscores the pressure on celebrities to define and defend their identities in the public eye—especially when earlier comments are held under constant review by online communities.