Log In

10 Best Picture Nominees From the '90s That Have Been Forgotten

Published 1 month ago9 minute read

The Academy Award for Best Picture is among the most important and coveted honors in the entertainment industry. Given by the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences, the Best Picture Oscar anoints a specific movie as the best of its respective year. Previous winners include timeless classics like , , and .

The 1990s were a particularly strong decade for Best Picture, with many iconic movies like and winning the prize. However, not every nominee is a timeless classic: For every , which is deeply influential and still remembered today, there's a , which many will not even recognize by name alone. This list will highlight those Best Picture nominees of the '90s that have been forgotten, whether because of their stronger competition or their safe and, in some cases, mediocrity.

Robin Williams and Robert De Niro as Sean and Leonard working on Leonard's arm therapy in the film Awakenings
Image via Columbia Pictures

's 1990 biopic stars the late as Dr. Malcolm Sayer, who discovers the benefits of the drug L-DOPA in 1969. He administers it to catatonic patients, including Leonard Lowe (), who must deal with a new world and attempt to rebuild his life with Sayer's help.

Although Awakenings comes dangerously close to becoming a melodrama, Williams and an Oscar-nominated De Niro prevent it from descending into cheap sentimentality. The film is well-known, or at least well enough; however, , which he lost against 's cunning portrayal of Claus von Bülow in . Awakenings' Best Picture nomination is further eclipsed by the sheer strength of its competitors, which included , , and .

0138382_poster_w780.jpg

Awakenings

December 4, 1990

Penny Marshall

Robert De Niro , Robin Williams , John Heard , Julie Kavner , Penelope Ann Miller , Ruth Nelson , Max von Sydow , Anne Meara , Dexter Gordon , George Martin , Alice Drummond , Richard Libertini , Laura Esterman , Barton Heyman , Judith Malina , Mary Alice , Keith Diamond , Bradley Whitford , John Christopher Jones , Mary Catherine Wright , Jayne Haynes , Le Clanché du Rand , Yusef Bulos , Steven Randazzo , Gloria Harper

120 minutes

Steven Zaillian

Warren Beatty as Bugsy Siegel in Bugsy
Image Via TriStar Pictures

1991 was a peculiar year. Everyone remembers the Best Picture winner, the seminal and game-changing . However, , with many outright forgetting them. Such is the case for 's gangster biopic , starring Oscar winner and Oscar nominee .

At the 1992 ceremony, Bugsy was actually the most nominated movie, with 10, including Best Actor for Beatty and dual Supporting Actor nominations for and . Bugsy is a very solid gangster biopic, and Beatty is as dashing as ever. However, the film's legacy might actually be reduced to being the starting point for Beatty and Bening's decades-long relationship.

bugsy-poster.jpg

Bugsy

December 10, 1991

Barry Levinson

Warren Beatty , Annette Bening , Harvey Keitel , Ben Kingsley , Elliott Gould , Joe Mantegna , Bebe Neuwirth , Bill Graham , Lewis van Bergen , Wendy Phillips , Richard C. Sarafian , Karen Russell , Robert Beltran , Stefanie Mason , Kimberly McCullough , Andy Romano , Bryan Smith , Eric Christmas

134 minutes

Dean Jennings , James Toback

Kevin Costner's Jim Garrison and Donald Sutherland's X standing together in JFK
Image via Warner Bros. 

1991 also produced 's political thriller . Starring Oscar winner , the film follows DA Jim Garrison (Costner), whose investigation into the murder of John F. Kennedy leads him to believe there is a conspiracy behind it and that Lee Harvey Oswald () is just a scapegoat.

JFK was actually quite controversial at the time, as it presented conspiracy theories that many considered exploitative. However, it was a box office success and accrued eight Oscar nominations, including Best Picture. Alas, JFK is nowadays best remembered as a paranoid thriller of the '90s and one of Stone's last great movies. However, .

jfk.jpg

JFK

December 20, 1991

Oliver Stone

Sally Kirkland , Anthony Ramirez , Ray LePere , Steve Reed , Jodie Farber , Columbia Dubose

189 minutes

Oliver Stone , Zachary Sklar , Jim Garrison , Jim Marrs

Barbra Streisand standing in front of Nick Nolte in The Prince of Tides (1991)
Image via Columbia Pictures

The last forgotten of the Best Picture nominees of 1991 has to be , directed by . Based on the eponymous 1986 novel, the film stars as a troubled man who develops a close and eventually romantic bond with the psychiatrist treating him.

Nowadays, The Prince of Tides is best remembered as . Indeed, it received seven Oscar nominations, including Best Picture, but Streisand was left out of both the Best Director and Best Actress categories. The controversy was such that even host commented on it during his opening monologue by asking if the film had "directed itself." For all its accomplishments, The Prince of Tides will always be .

The Prince of Tides Movie Poster

The Prince of Tides

December 25, 1991

Barbra Streisand

Nick Nolte , Barbra Streisand , Blythe Danner , Kate Nelligan , Jeroen Krabbé , Melinda Dillon , George Carlin , Jason Gould , Brad Sullivan

132 Minutes

Pat Conroy , Becky Johnston

Ralph Fiennes listening to a question in Quiz Show
Image via Walt Disney Studios

1994 had arguably the best line-up for Best Picture: Pulp Fiction, , , and have all become all-time classics in their respective genres and modern icons of cinema. But what about the fifth and final nominee? Well, that would be 's magnificent, based on the Twenty-One quiz show scandals of the 1950s.

Make no mistake, Quiz Show is a brilliant movie more than deserving of its Best Picture nomination and, in any other year, the win. Excellent performances from and an Oscar-worthy only enhance its strengths. However, it has simply , which remain beloved and immensely popular today. Despite all it does right, Quiz Show is simply no competition for the likes of Pulp Fiction.

Massimo Troisi and Maria Grazia Cucinotta in 'Il Postino' (1)
Image via Miramax

The 1996 Best Picture line-up included four icons of the '90s: , , , and the eventual winner, . The fifth nominee was the Italian film , in which a humble postman () forms a deep connection with the Chilean poet Pablo Neruda.

Aside from the fact that the Chilean icon is played by a French actor, Il Postino is a great movie, a lovely exploration of friendship and love. The thoughtful story is further enhanced by a powerful performance from Troisi, who received a posthumous Oscar nomination for his work. However, , and Il Postino was no exception. It was widely lauded at the time, but thirty years later, few remember it, especially compared to its fellow nominees.

bKey2XnAKJyeGuNZTQ9cs9m1hSC

Il Postino: The Postman

June 16, 1995

Michael Radford

Massimo Troisi , Philippe Noiret , Maria Grazia Cucinotta , Renato Scarpa , Linda Moretti , Mariano Rigillo , Anna Bonaiuto , Simona Caparrini

108 Minutes

Anna Pavignano , Michael Radford , Furio Scarpelli , Giacomo Scarpelli , Massimo Troisi

Geoffrey Rush as David Helfgott in 'Shine' (1996)
Image via Roadshow Films

Biopics are catnip for the Academy. Indeed, it loves few things more than to reward movies about meaningful figures, usually highlighting at least one or two every year. In 1996, the big biopic was ' , which starred as David Helfgott, a pianist who spent years in institutions after suffering a mental breakdown.

Rush received the Academy Award for Best Actor, a win that most people remember, even if they don't exactly know what movie he won for. However, Shine's actual Best Picture nomination might take more than a few by surprise. In fact, Shine was huge at the 1997 ceremony, receiving seven nominations, but Rush was its only victory. Still, the fact that it received across-the-board recognition speaks to its popularity with contemporary critics; not too bad for .

01344527_poster_w780.jpg

Shine

August 15, 1996

Scott Hicks

Armin Mueller-Stahl , Noah Taylor , Geoffrey Rush , Lynn Redgrave , Googie Withers , Sonia Todd , Nicholas Bell , John Gielgud , Justin Braine , Chris Haywood , Alex Rafalowicz , Gordon Poole , Danielle Cox , Rebecca Gooden , Marta Kaczmarek , John Cousins , Paul Linkson , Randall Berger , Phyllis Burford , Daphne Grey , Edwin Hodgeman , Stephen Sheehan , Brenton Whittle , Marianna Doherty , Camilla James

105 minutes

Jan Sardi

Cast of The Full Monty looking ahead
Image Via Fox Searchlight Pictures

Comedies are so rarely honored at the Oscars that when one is actually acknowledged with a Best Picture nomination, it's a cause for celebration. Such was the case in 1997 when 's delightful British comedy received a Best Picture nod.

Sadly, The Full Monty was against four of the strongest Best Picture contenders of the '90s: , , , and, of course, Titanic. The Full Monty is far more popular in the UK, where it actually won the BAFTA Award for Best Film. However, in the West, , all of which have aged well and remain highly popular with both critics and audiences. At least The Full Monty can flaunt its status as a Best Picture nominee.

The Full Monty Movie Poster

The Full Monty

August 13, 1997

Peter Cattaneo

Robert Carlyle , Tom Wilkinson , Mark Addy , Wim Snape , Steve Huison , Paul Barber , Hugo Speer , Lesley Sharp

91 Minutes

Simon Beaufoy

Michael Caine in 'The Cider House Rules'
Image via Miramax Films

The first Oscars of the millennium honored several great movies, most notably and the eventual winner for Best Picture, . However, two of the five nominees have fallen out of popularity; the first is 's , based on John Irving's eponymous 1985 novel. It follows a young orphan who becomes a skilled physician in World War II, Maine.

Today, The Cider House Rules is best remembered as the film that gave Sir another Oscar over fellow nominees (and arguably worthier winners) and the late . However, the film was actually a huge performer that year, also winning the Oscar for Best Adapted Screenplay and receiving five additional nominations. , but voters went gaga for it in 2000.

the-cider-house-rules-poster.jpg

The Cider House Rules

December 17, 1999

Lasse Hallström

Tobey Maguire , Charlize Theron , Delroy Lindo , Paul Rudd , Michael Caine , Jane Alexander , Kathy Baker , Erykah Badu , Kieran Culkin , Kate Nelligan , Heavy D , J.K. Simmons , Erik Per Sullivan , Paz de la Huerta , K. Todd Freeman , Evan Parke , Jimmy Flynn , Lonnie Farmer , Spencer Diamond , Skye McCole Bartusiak , Sean Andrew

126 Minutes

John Irving

Lowell Bergman (Al Pacino) staring offscreen with Dr. Jeffrey Wigand (Russell Crowe) appearing on a television behind him in 'The Insider'
Image via Buena Vista Pictures Distribution

The second of the five nominees in 2000 that has been somewhat forgotten is the -directed and Al Pacino and Russell Crowe-starring biopic The Insider. It chronicles the controversial 60 Minutes segment about whistleblower Jeffrey Wingard (Crowe), with Pacino playing veteran CBS producer Lowell Bergman.

When discussing Mann's oeuvre from the '90s, his seminal action thriller Heat and the 1992 epic drama The Last of the Mohicans usually take precedence. However, The Insider is among his strongest efforts, a tense and tight drama that offers a detailed and riveting picture of one of the biggest scandals of the '90s. In the years since, Mann's other movies have pretty much dwarfed The Insider, but that doesn't make the movie any less poignant.

jjcyibpfvk41uetq6k6u4upygo8.jpg

The Insider

Release Date
November 5, 1999

Director
Michael Mann

Cast
Russell Crowe , Al Pacino , Christopher Plummer , Diane Venora , Philip Baker Hall , Lindsay Crouse , Debi Mazar , Stephen Tobolowsky

Runtime
157 Minutes

Writers
Marie Brenner , Eric Roth , Michael Mann

NEXT: All 96 Best Picture Oscar Winners, Ranked

Origin:
publisher logo
Collider
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

You may also like...