Published on January 28, 2025 09:29PM EST

Jimmy Fallon can officially add Broadway to his list of accomplishments!

The Tonight Show host made his Broadway debut on Tuesday, Jan. 28, joining the all-star cast of All In: Comedy About Love by Simon Rich.

Photographers were on hand at the Hudson Theatre in New York City to capture Fallon amid the milestone. He's starring in the show alongside Lin-Manuel Miranda, Aidy Bryant and Nick Kroll.

Bryant also made her Broadway debut with All In, when she joined the cast on Jan. 14. The Saturday Night Live alumna finishes performances on Feb. 2, the same day Fallon and Kroll are scheduled to wrap their runs.

All In has boasted an all-star cast since the beginning, with John Mulaney, Fred Armisen, Richard Kind and Tony winner Renée Elise Goldsberry opening the show back in December.

Playing a limited 10-week production through Feb. 16, the rotating cast still has four big names coming down the line: David Cross (Feb. 4 – 9), Tony winner Annaleigh Ashford (Feb. 4 – 16), Tim Meadows (Feb. 4 – 16) and Hank Azaria (Feb. 11 – 16).

Other stars in the show have included Andrew Rannells and Chloe Fineman.

The play, directed by Alex Timbers, features original stories about dating, heartbreak, marriage and more by humorist Rich — a former writer on SNL (which could explain why so many SNL stars past and present, including Fallon, have been a part of its cast). SNL's Lorne Michaels is among its producers.

In between stories, The Bengsons (Abigail and Shaun Bengson) perform songs from The Magnetic Fields , including tunes from the popular album 69 Love Songs.

"Even though the show’s kind of all over the place, [All In is] meant to tell one simple story: that the most important part of life is who we share it with," the show's official description said in a release. "We hope everybody will relate to it, even if it was their date’s idea to come and they are starting out from a place of quiet resentment."

"It’s everything you want in a night out ‚ laughter, romance, live music and people you recognize from television –all in 90 unforgettable minutes," they added.

Tickets to All In are now on sale.